Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Feminism and the City


Sex and the City. The "shocking, groundbreaking, and innovative" (Warren 4) television series of 1998. Never before had a television series gone where Sex and the City went: a show about four very powerful single women living in New York City who openly discuss their successful jobs and sex lives. This show is surprisingly often associated with feminism. Not "butch, hairy, angry, man-hunting, anti-marriage, anti-pornography, bra-burning, dungaree-wearing lesbians" (Warren 1) but feminism in the sense that women can be as successful and as powerful as men. Feminism has developed a negative connotation, but SATC strove to take this negative connotation and make it positive; feminism can be sexy too. The show began, documentary style, really aiming to stress the power women could attain (keyword: power), but by season six the show had turned almost completely to the fact that the women were madly in love with their men in typical television sit-com style: the show now basically focused all of their "man issues". Uplifts Magazine's blog post Sex, Shoes, Cosmos, and... Feminism? raises this interesting question: did SATC lose hope on the feminism idea and turn to the old 'women need men' lifestyle, or can strong women desire a husband too?
Sex and the City did not lose hope on the feminist idea, rather the show beat the feminist stereotype. Just because the girls of the show strut the streets of New York City clothed in Dior dresses, Manolo Blahnik stilettos, and carrying Birkin bags “does not deny them the right to seek advancement, empowerment, and equality” (Scott) in the world. Women have the ability to be powerful while looking good. People have convinced themselves of the stereotype that if a women cares about her appearance, she must not be powerful. Only ugly women who wear tacky pantsuits can be powerful. No offense society, but what a dumb idea. The feminist side of SATC put it in society’s face that this stereotype must be defeated. There are powerful women everywhere who can do anything, and maybe even more, that any man can do.
But is there a man behind all of these successful women? According to SATC, there is not. And I completely agree. Women have the ability to stand powerfully on their own without a man helping them out. For example, character of the show Miranda Hobbs is a single (for most of the show) successful lawyer, and she got there without a man. Once she had all of her success, she married a much-less-successful-than-her bartender. Miranda got married not because society told her it was right to do so (Miranda is the type who could care less about having a husband) but because she wanted to get married. She was a strong woman, and desiring a husband did not make her any weaker. Women have the ability to multitask. So why is society so against powerful women who are multitasking by working hard and finding themselves a man? The idea that powerful women desire men scares some men: no man, unless he is completely secure with his masculinity and couldn’t care what society thinks, wants to be less powerful than his wife. Society looks down upon these men, which leads to society looking down on powerful women also desiring men. Miranda’s relationship was worked into the show to prove to society that men, even if they initially feel threatened by a woman’s success, can date successful women and still be accepted by society.
Sex and the City taught viewers that you do not have to be a stereotypical feminist to support women with power. And women in power are not weakened if they have a boyfriend or husband. Society needs to accept the fact that women are becoming more powerful and that there is no reason to be threatened by the rising female success. Men used to be the hunters, the heads of the household, the providers, and many men still are, but it is just recently starting to be acceptable for women to be providers too- something butch and sexy feminists have been fighting for for ages. There is nothing wrong with being a feminist, and there is nothing wrong with being an anti-feminist, but there is something wrong with stereotyping women for their views on feminism.

Works Cited

Warren, Holly. "Sex, Shoes, Cosmos, and... Feminism? ." Weblog post. Uplift
Magazine . 29 Jan. 2009. 18 Feb. 2009 .


Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Socratic Seminar Questions: Gender

"Girl"
  • Examine the rules of groups in society today
  • Is this poem just stating the rules or is it stereotyping women?

"X"
  • What is your general opinion of the story?
  • Could an "X" ever survive in today's society? Is this story realistic?
  • What problems (socially and mentally) could a child develop if it is raised as an "X"?
  • Do you think that making children "X's" and "Y's" is a healthy choice to destroy the gender stereotypes in today's society?

"Trifles"
  • What is your general opinion of the story?
  • Who pays more attention to detail? The men or the women? Is this a stereotype or scientific?
  • Examine the differences between the male and female characters in the play

"WHMS"
  • Can men and women ever be just friends?

Tying it all together...
  • Does society have rules or are we stereotyping?
  • What has made men and women so different: society or science?

Friday, February 6, 2009

My Group

Everyone belongs to a group. Every group has rules. And these groups make up a diverse society. People cannot avoid being categorized into groups that compose not only who they are, but where they fall in society. The poem Girl by Jamaica Kincaid breaks down the rules to be in the domestic women group. To be categorized as a domestic woman, according to Kincaid, you must follow these rules. 
Using the Kincaid's poem as a model, I wrote about one of my favorite groups. I belong to the "MSC Lifeguard" group. No one will understand the poem fully, unless they are in my group, just like I did not fully understand the rules of Kincaid's domestic women group because I am far from domestic. 

MSC Lifeguards
Cheat on your lifeguarding test; take your lifeguarding test in a group; you have to be able to play ping-pong; on rainy days, you have to be amazing at Taboo; you must not put your feet up on chair; but I never put my feet up on chair; never paint your nails when you are sitting gate; do not put chairs in the kiddie pool; you must blow your whistle; you must blow your whistle three times when someone is drowning; you must not blow your whistle three times if there is no emergency; you are not allowed to roll down the straps on your bathing suit; but I never roll down my straps, Caroline does, but I have never; listen to the owner of Our Pizza House tell you all about his $500 water filtration system; you must use soap when cleaning the bathrooms; no, just spraying water on the floor does not mean they have been cleaned; refer to your manager as Joe Norris, named after Chuck Norris; get rid of all the frogs in the pool; you must not put your feet up on chair; check everyone’s card; but Caitie is my friend and I know she is a member but she never has her card; you must not let Caitie into the swim club if she forgets her card one more time; order lunch from Marc’s; you will pick up turkey on a whole wheat wrap with lettuce and honey mustard on the side for Joe everyday when you go to Marc’s; learn to love buffalo chicken pizza and refer to it as buff chick; be very quiet when you break into the swim club at midnight after the guard party when the managers go to a bar; when you get caught, hop the fence in the back right corner of the pool to escape the cops; you must remember to take your car keys out of the pump house before then; you do not want to work Wednesday nights or Thursday mornings; we pull chairs Wednesday nights; we put them back Thursday mornings; you must not put your feet up on chair; if you can avoid it, do not volunteer to get Dolly out of her car; you will pass out if you smell Dolly’s car; do not under any circumstance ask Dolly if she wants her cane, she thinks she can walk without it; she can’t; you must be tall and blonde and thin to be Dolly’s Next Top Model; but she told me I have a nice figure; you are not blonde, you cannot be a model; but she told me I have great legs; you are not blonde, you cannot be a model; no child can wear swimmies in the pool; do not let children wear diapers in the pool; you will get very bad tan lines from your lifeguard bathing suit; and most importantly, you must follow all of these rules and understand all of these inside jokes to be a MSC Lifeguard.